Enterprise Tech

BlackRock Tops New AI Index as Asset Managers Face a Returns Test

Evident’s first asset-management index highlights expanding AI capabilities and a shortage of comparable public evidence on financial benefits.

By Olivia Grant Edited by Maria Konash Published: Updated:
BlackRock Tops New AI Index as Asset Managers Face a Returns Test
BlackRock leads Evident’s first asset-management AI index, while public disclosure of financial benefits remains limited. Photo: Andres Daza / Pexels

Key Notes

  • BlackRock, Vanguard and Fidelity lead Evident’s first AI maturity ranking of 30 asset managers.
  • The index uses public information to assess talent, innovation, leadership and responsible AI transparency.
  • Only three assessed firms have publicly quantified projected or realized returns from AI across their businesses.

BlackRock has taken first place in Evident’s inaugural AI maturity index for asset managers, followed by Vanguard and Fidelity. Published on November 17, the ranking covers 30 firms in North America and Europe.

The more difficult question is how those capabilities translate into money. Only three firms have publicly quantified projected or realized returns from AI across their businesses. InvestmentNews reported that the limited disclosure makes industry-wide comparisons difficult even as deployment expands.

What the Ranking Measures

Evident’s methodology uses more than 70 indicators drawn entirely from public information. Talent carries 45% of the score, innovation 25%, leadership 20% and transparency 10%. Leadership covers public communication and executive positioning; transparency concerns responsible AI activities.

This is a comparison of observable organizational capabilities. It does not show that the top-ranked manager will outperform in a fund, that its models make the best trading decisions, or that every internal deployment has been examined. An assessment built from public data also depends on what a company chooses to disclose.

Fidelity’s position illustrates the importance of research capacity. InvestmentNews reported that the firm accounted for 34% of AI workers, 43% of AI research output and 78% of AI patents identified across the assessed companies. Those percentages describe shares of the dataset, rather than the proportion of Fidelity employees using AI or assets managed by it.

BlackRock’s Platform Offers a Concrete Example

A presentation by BlackRock engineers for this week’s QCon San Francisco conference describes how the firm’s Asimov investment research platform brings together data, investment context and specialized agents. Its continuous monitoring processes approximately 150,000 documents weekly across 10,000 companies, according to the session abstract.

The engineers also report more than 1,000 dashboards and applications created by users, with over 30 added to a shared catalog. The architecture separates data, intelligence and applications, while retaining common security and access controls. These are the company’s descriptions of its system, rather than an independent audit of its investment results.

The example helps explain what AI maturity can mean in practice: a reusable system that updates research and supports multiple teams. Processing more documents is a useful operating measure, but establishing its financial contribution requires a further step, such as comparing analyst time, research quality or decisions against an appropriate baseline.

The Financial Evidence Is Still Uneven

Commercial functions offer some clearer reported outcomes. InvestmentNews’s account of Evident’s findings says Franklin Templeton reported an 11% sales uplift and a 25% increase in client contacts in regions using its AI-powered Intelligence Hub. These are distribution measures, rather than returns earned by an investment portfolio.

The report does not make those figures a controlled estimate of AI’s contribution. Results can depend on the period measured, the teams involved and other changes to the business. Equally, a lack of public figures does not establish that a firm has gained nothing from the technology.

For a useful comparison, managers would need to distinguish projected benefits from realized ones, disclose implementation and supervision costs, and explain what would have happened without the system. Savings, additional sales and investment performance answer different questions. Combining them under a single claim of AI returns can conceal more than it reveals.

Evident’s index gives the industry a starting point for comparing capability. The next test is whether firms can connect that capability to clearly defined, repeatable financial outcomes.

Disclaimer: AIstify is an independent media brand owned and operated by NuvexMedia LLC, publishing news, research, and insights on artificial intelligence, emerging technologies, automation, and related industries. NuvexMedia LLC invests in and collaborates with companies across the AI, technology, software, and digital innovation sectors. These relationships do not influence AIstify’s editorial coverage, and the publication maintains full editorial independence to provide accurate, timely, and objective information. © 2026 NuvexMedia LLC. All rights reserved. This content is for informational purposes only and should not be considered legal, tax, investment, financial, or other professional advice.

AI & Machine Learning, Enterprise Tech, News